The Absolute Best Pies in Garland [Updated 2025]

Having personally tasted and reviewed numerous pies in the area, I can confidently say that these three establishments have truly mastered the art of pie-making. From flaky crusts to mouthwatering fillings, each pie on this list has been carefully selected to deliver an exceptional culinary experience.

Join me on this delightful journey as we explore the vibrant and diverse pie scene in Garland, taking a closer look at what sets these pies apart and why they have earned the title of the best pies in town. Get ready to indulge your taste buds and discover your new favorite pie destination in Garland!

Piefalootin

Highlights
Best pecan pie
Personalable owner
Large selection of pies
Huge portions
Good prices

Let me begin by saying that I have found what may be the best pecan pie in all of Garland at Piefalootin. From the moment I set foot in this charming pie shop, I could tell I was in for a treat.

One of the highlights of my visit was the personalable owner who greeted me with a warm smile and a genuine enthusiasm for his pies. He graciously guided me through the large selection of pies on display, each one more tempting than the last.

Now, let's talk about the pies themselves. The first thing that struck me was the huge portions. Piefalootin certainly doesn't skimp on serving size! The slices were generous and satisfying, and each pie was bursting with flavor.

But what truly impressed me was the good prices. Piefalootin offers incredible value for the quality of their pies. I couldn't believe I was getting such delicious, handmade pies at such reasonable prices.

If you find yourself in Garland craving a slice of pie, I highly recommend paying Piefalootin a visit. Their best pecan pie alone is worth the trip. Treat yourself to a delightful experience at Piefalootin, where the pies are both playful and professional.

You might also want to check out the best seafood boil in Dallas.

Humble: Simply Good Pies

Highlights
Delicious flavors
Perfect sweetness
Fresh ingredients
Generous filling

When I entered Humble: Simply Good Pies, I was welcomed by the delightful scent of freshly baked pies, setting the stage for a memorable experience ahead. As I perused their menu, I couldn't help but notice the array of delicious flavors they offered. From classic apple to indulgent chocolate cream, there was a pie to satisfy every craving.

I decided to try their signature pecan pie, and oh boy, was it a delectable treat. The crust was perfectly flaky, adding a delightful texture to each bite. The filling was generously packed with pecans, providing a delightful nutty flavor with every mouthful. The balance of sweetness was just right, not overpowering but leaving a lingering taste that left me craving for more.

One thing that truly set Humble apart was their commitment to using fresh ingredients. Each pie was made with care and attention, resulting in a mouthwatering creation that tasted like it was homemade. The quality of their ingredients was evident in every bite, and it made each pie a true delight.

A standout feature of Humble's pies was their generous filling. There was no skimping on the goodness here. Every pie was overflowing with a rich and flavorful filling that left me satisfied and smiling.

In conclusion, if you're looking for the best pies in Garland, Humble: Simply Good Pies is a must-visit destination. Their pies are a true embodiment of their name - humble yet undeniably good. The experience of savoring their perfectly crafted pies with their delicious flavors, perfect sweetness, fresh ingredients, and generous fillings is not one to be missed.

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Grapevine.

1950's Diner Pie Shakes Ice Cream

Highlights
Fun atmosphere
Delicious ice cream
Friendly staff
Great food and sodas
Nostalgic decor

Walking into 1950's Diner Pie Shakes Ice Cream, I was immediately transported back in time. The nostalgic decor took me on a journey to the era of poodle skirts and rock 'n' roll. The staff greeted me with a warm smile, immediately making me feel at home in this fun atmosphere.

Now, let's talk about the star of the show: the pies. Oh boy, were they delicious! I couldn't resist trying their classic apple pie. The crust was perfectly flaky, and the filling had just the right balance of sweetness and tartness. Each bite was a slice of heaven, making me feel like I was tasting a homemade pie made with love.

But 1950's Diner Pie Shakes Ice Cream doesn't stop at pies. Their ice cream is to die for! I indulged in a scoop of their homemade vanilla ice cream and was blown away by the rich flavor and creamy texture. It was the perfect accompaniment to the warm pie.

The friendly staff made my visit even more enjoyable. They were attentive and knowledgeable, happily recommending their favorite pie and ice cream combinations. It felt like meeting old friends.

The menu at 1950's Diner Pie Shakes Ice Cream doesn't stop at pies and ice cream. They also offer a range of great food and sodas. Whether you're craving a juicy burger or a refreshing milkshake, they have it all.

If you're looking for a place that combines nostalgia, great food, and delectable pies, look no further than 1950's Diner Pie Shakes Ice Cream in Garland. It's a place where you can indulge in a sweet trip down memory lane in a playful yet professional atmosphere.

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Dallas.