McKinney's Best Pizza [Updated 2025]

In my quest to find the most mouthwatering and delicious pizzas in McKinney, I have tirelessly researched and reviewed ten different establishments. From thin and crispy crusts to thick and cheesy slices, I have left no stone unturned in my pursuit of the perfect pie.

Join me as I unveil the top contenders, sharing not only their savory creations but also the ambiance and service that make them stand out from the rest. Whether you're a local looking for a go-to spot or a visitor seeking an unforgettable pizza experience, this article is your gateway to discovering the very best pizza McKinney has to offer.

Cadillac Pizza Pub

Highlights
Staff: welcoming, experienced, hardworking
Food: consistently good, lots of choices
Sedona Salad - best in McKinney
Location: off the downtown square
Drinks: good selection, cold beer
Value: great value for the experience
Vibe: a fun place to hang out
Wood-fired pizzas bursting with flavor
Outstanding salads and appetizers
Exceptional service, friendly and attentive staff

Walking into Cadillac Pizza Pub, I immediately felt the welcoming vibe that everyone had been raving about. The staff was experienced, hardworking, and went out of their way to make sure I had a great dining experience.

Now, let's talk about the star of the show - the pizza. Cadillac Pizza Pub consistently delivers mouthwatering pizzas with their wood-fired oven that adds a unique smoky flavor. Each bite was bursting with flavor, and I was amazed at the variety of choices they had on their menu. The Crispy Margherita and The Cadillac were personal favorites, but you can't go wrong with any of their options.

But wait, there's more! The Sedona Salad stole the show as the best salad in McKinney. The combination of mixed greens, candied pecans, goat cheese, and a tangy balsamic vinaigrette created a delightful explosion of flavors in my mouth.

The location of Cadillac Pizza Pub, just off the downtown square, adds to its charm. It's the perfect spot to grab a delicious pizza and enjoy the vibrant atmosphere of McKinney.

To wash down their incredible pizzas and salads, Cadillac Pizza Pub offers a good selection of drinks, including cold beer that complements their pizzas perfectly.

What impressed me most was the great value Cadillac Pizza Pub offers. With exceptional food, outstanding service, and a fun environment, their prices are more than fair.

In conclusion, Cadillac Pizza Pub in McKinney is a true gem. With their wood-fired pizzas bursting with flavor, outstanding salads and appetizers, exceptional service, and friendly and attentive staff, this place truly deserves its reputation as one of the best pizza places in town. Be sure to check it out!

You might also want to check out the best ramen in Dallas.

Cavalli Pizza Napoletana

Highlights
Fresh ingredients
House made cheese
Brick oven pizza
Great pasta
Top notch service

From the moment I stepped into Cavalli Pizza Napoletana, I knew I was in for a treat. The inviting aroma of freshly baked pizza filled the air, immediately putting a smile on my face.

One of the highlights of Cavalli Pizza Napoletana is their use of fresh ingredients. Every bite I took was bursting with flavor and I could taste the difference that quality ingredients made. From the vibrant tomatoes to the fragrant basil, each topping was a delight to the taste buds.

Their commitment to excellence doesn't stop at the toppings. The house made cheese was creamy and rich, adding a luxurious touch to each slice. I could tell that the cheese had been crafted with care, resulting in a melt-in-your-mouth experience.

But the true star of the show at Cavalli Pizza Napoletana is their brick oven pizza. Each pie is cooked to perfection, with a crispy yet chewy crust that is simply divine. The high heat of the oven creates a beautiful char on the edges, adding a delightful smoky flavor to the overall experience.

Beyond the pizza, Cavalli also offers a selection of great pasta dishes. Whether you're in the mood for classic spaghetti or a creamy fettuccine alfredo, their pasta dishes are cooked to perfection and sure to satisfy any craving.

Lastly, I must mention the top-notch service at Cavalli Pizza Napoletana. The staff was friendly, attentive, and knowledgeable about the menu. They made my dining experience comfortable and enjoyable, ensuring that I had everything I needed.

Overall, Cavalli Pizza Napoletana in McKinney is a must-visit for any pizza enthusiast. Their commitment to using fresh ingredients, handcrafted cheese, and cooking in a traditional brick oven sets them apart from the rest. So, grab a seat, indulge in some delicious pizza, and let Cavalli take your taste buds on a journey you won't soon forget.

You might also want to check out the best dessert in Dallas.

New York Pizza and Pints II

Highlights
Daily lunch special
Slice bigger than a newborn baby
Stubborn Pineapple Cream Soda
Close to NY style pizza
Friendly and clean environment

Walking into New York Pizza and Pints II, I was immediately drawn to the vibrant and clean environment. With a warm welcome from the staff, I knew I was in for a treat.

The menu boasted an impressive array of options, but the daily lunch special caught my eye. Being a pizza enthusiast, I couldn't resist trying their famous slice, rumored to be bigger than a newborn baby. Let me tell you, those rumors were not exaggerated. This slice was a monster in all the right ways - crispy crust, gooey cheese, and toppings that were generously piled high.

To accompany my pizza, I decided to be adventurous and ordered the Stubborn Pineapple Cream Soda. It was a delightful blend of sweet, tangy, and fizzy that perfectly complemented the flavors of the pizza.

Being a connoisseur of New York-style pizza, I was thrilled to find that their pizza's thin crust was just like what you'd find in the Big Apple. The flavors were spot on, with each ingredient playing its part harmoniously.

But what really set New York Pizza and Pints II apart was the friendly and welcoming atmosphere. The staff made me feel like a part of their pizza-loving family, providing excellent service throughout my visit.

In conclusion, New York Pizza and Pints II is a hidden gem offering a slice of New York right here in McKinney. With their daily lunch special, slice bigger than a newborn baby, and the unique Stubborn Pineapple Cream Soda, this place is truly a pizza lover's paradise. Be prepared to be amazed by their close-to-authentic New York-style pizza in a friendly and clean environment.

You might also want to check out the best fried chicken in Dallas.

Sicily's Pizza & Pasta

I have tasted many pizzas in my quest for the best pie in McKinney, and I must say that Sicily's Pizza & Pasta truly delivers. The combination of fresh ingredients, thin and crispy crust, and generous toppings creates a flavor explosion in every bite. It's a pizza party in your mouth! Buon appetito!

You might also want to check out the best korean bbq in Dallas.

Barro's Pizza

Barro's Pizza in McKinney is a hidden gem that brings a burst of flavor to your tastebuds. With their perfectly crafted crust and generous toppings, every bite delivers a mouthwatering explosion. Playful and professional, this pizzeria is a must-visit for pizza enthusiasts.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in North Dallas.

Pizza Twist

Pizza Twist in McKinney is a fun and vibrant spot for pizza lovers. Their creative twist on classic flavors is sure to leave your taste buds dancing. Mouthwatering toppings and a fluffy crust make each bite a delight. Don't miss their signature twist!

You might also want to check out the best pho in Dallas.

Rosati’s Pizza

Rosati's Pizza in McKinney is a flavorful slice of heaven. The crust is crispy while the cheese is ooey-gooey perfection. The toppings are abundant and the sauce is tangy yet well-balanced. Every bite is a delicious adventure. Give it a try and you'll be saying "that's amore!"

You might also want to check out the best diners in Dallas.

Mellow Mushroom McKinney

The moment I stepped into Mellow Mushroom McKinney, I was greeted by a groovy atmosphere adorned with vibrant decor and artwork. The aroma of freshly baked dough filled the air, making my taste buds dance with anticipation.

I ordered their signature Holy Shiitake Pie, topped with a heavenly combination of shiitake, button, portobello mushrooms, and a mouthwatering blend of mozzarella, garlic, and olive oil. The crust was perfectly crispy, providing a satisfying crunch with every bite.

The pizza was a work of art, with the toppings evenly distributed and generously proportioned. Each mushroom had a rich, earthy flavor that paired harmoniously with the melted cheese. The hints of garlic added a nice kick, enhancing the overall taste.

The service was exceptional, with the staff being friendly and attentive. They truly went above and beyond to ensure my dining experience was memorable.

If you're in search of a trippy, psychedelic pizza adventure, Mellow Mushroom McKinney is a must-visit. Their unique and delectable pizza creations will transport your taste buds to a dimension of flavor you won't want to leave.

You might also want to check out the best japanese restaurant in Dallas.

Durkin's Pizza

Durkin's Pizza in McKinney is a tantalizing treasure trove of taste bud titillation. Their thin crust pizza is perfection personified, with a delightful blend of quality ingredients that dance on your palate. From their mouthwatering Margherita to their savory BBQ Chicken, Durkin's is a pizza paradise worth visiting.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in McKinney.

Mckinney Pizza Tavern

McKinney Pizza Tavern in McKinney is a delightful spot for pizza lovers. The crust is crispy and the toppings are tantalizing. With a charming atmosphere and friendly service, this tavern is definitely a contender for the title of best pizza in McKinney.

You might also want to check out the best casual restaurants in Dallas.